Loading page
Preview data: all rankings, scores, votes, refresh labels, methodology, testing and editorial-process statements in Top 49 are illustrative demo content, not live measurements or documented reviews.
Rank 114Down 4Editor’s pick
#11 in Podcasts of All Time
of 18 ranked entries
Reply All
PJ Vogt & Alex Goldman · Gimlet Media · 2014–2023
Vogt and Goldman built a show ostensibly about the internet that was really about human behavior filtered through technology, and its best episodes — like the "Long Distance" scam investigation — hold up as some of the tightest audio journalism made this decade. Recorded specifics: launched 2014, host PJ Vogt & Alex Goldman, network Gimlet Media. Panel highlighted "The Case of the Missing Hit" and "Long Distance" remain genre-defining episodes, genuine chemistry between hosts that never felt performed for the format and tackled internet culture with real reporting rather than just commentary. The reservation on record is ended in 2023 after internal workplace controversies undercut the show’s credibility.
CultureComedy
Score breakdown
How Reply All earned 82.1
Each criterion is scored independently, then combined using the weights published on Podcasts of All Time.
- Editorial & production craftweight 30%
- 83.0
- Storytelling ambitionweight 25%
- 81.6
- Cultural influenceweight 25%
- 79.5
- Consistency across episodesweight 20%
- 84.4
On the record
Recorded detail
| Launched | 2014 |
|---|---|
| Host | PJ Vogt & Alex Goldman |
| Network | Gimlet Media |
| Rating | 8.7 |
Panel verdict
Strengths and reservations
What it gets right
- "The Case of the Missing Hit" and "Long Distance" remain genre-defining episodes
- Genuine chemistry between hosts that never felt performed for the format
- Tackled internet culture with real reporting rather than just commentary
Where it gives ground
- Ended in 2023 after internal workplace controversies undercut the show’s credibility
1 appearance
Where this entry ranks
From the same list
Ranked alongside it
Rank 01Editor’s pickSerial
Sarah Koenig · Serial Productions · 2014
Koenig spun a This American Life segment into its own show and spent twelve episodes second-guessing a 1999 murder conviction in real time, essentially inventing the true-crime podcast format and the modern podcast industry’s commercial viability along with it.
97.7/100 Top 49 score1Up 1
Rank 02Editor’s pickThis American Life
Ira Glass · WBEZ Chicago · Since 1995
Glass built a weekly structure — theme, then acts — simple enough to become the default format for narrative audio, and three decades later almost every serious storytelling podcast is still working some variation of the template he standardized.
96.2/100 Top 49 score1Down 1
Rank 03Editor’s pickRadiolab
Jad Abumrad · WNYC · Since 2002
Abumrad treated sound design as a genuine storytelling tool rather than decoration, layering music and effects underneath science stories until the production itself became as much a part of the argument as the facts being reported.
95.0/100 Top 49 score—No change
Rank 04The Joe Rogan Experience
Joe Rogan · Since 2009
Rogan built the format on almost total absence of structure — three hours, one guest, whatever direction the conversation takes — and turned that shapelessness into the most consistently downloaded podcast on the planet.
93.5/100 Top 49 score1Up 1
Rank 05Hardcore History
Dan Carlin · Since 2006
Carlin releases episodes that regularly run four or five hours and treats that length as a feature — enough runtime to actually sit with the scale of, say, the Eastern Front, rather than compress it into a digestible summary.
91.1/100 Top 49 score1Up 1
Rank 06S-Town
Brian Reed · Serial Productions · 2017
Reed set out to investigate a small-town murder that turned out not to have happened, and the show pivoted entirely to profile its own tragic, brilliant subject instead — a structural risk that paid off into one of podcasting’s most acclaimed seasons.
90.0/100 Top 49 score—No change
Rank 07WTF with Marc Maron
Marc Maron · Since 2009
Maron recorded early episodes in his own garage and built the show on unusually candid, therapy-adjacent conversation, most famously getting a sitting U.S. president to sit down in that same garage in 2015.
88.7/100 Top 49 score3Down 3
Rank 08The Daily
Michael Barbaro · The New York Times · Since 2017
Barbaro and the Times built a twenty-minute weekday news briefing around a single story reported in real depth, and the format proved so effective that it became the most listened-to news podcast in the country within a couple of years.
86.4/100 Top 49 score4Down 4
Explore more of Top 49
Top 49 rankings are editorial. Scores are produced from the published criteria on each list and are refreshed on the cadence stated there. Figures shown across this section are curated demonstration data.