American Home Shield vs Asurion Home+
American Home Shield leads Asurion Home+ by 0.4 points overall (7.1 vs 6.7).
#3 in Home warranty & device protection plans
American Home Shield
US homeowners wanting systems and appliance cover
7.1/10, Good
6.7/10, Good
Criterion by criterion
Where each one wins
American Home Shield8.5
Tiered plans cover major systems and appliances together.
Coverage breadth
25% weight
Asurion Home+7.5
One plan for many eligible home-tech devices.
American Home Shield6.5
Price varies by address and fee choice, so quotes are needed.
Fee structure clarity
20% weight
Asurion Home+6.0
Monthly price is simple, but per-item claim terms need reading.
American Home Shield7.5
Claims online, by app or by phone.
Claims convenience
20% weight
Asurion Home+7.5
Online and phone claims, plus included tech support.
American Home Shield6.5
Uses a contractor network; you do not usually choose the technician.
Repair network & parts
20% weight
Asurion Home+7.0
Uses Asurion repair and replacement network.
American Home Shield5.5
US only.
Regional availability
15% weight
Asurion Home+5.0
US only.
Published facts
Side by side
| Fact | American Home Shield | Asurion Home+ |
|---|---|---|
| What it covers | Home systems (HVAC, plumbing, electrical) and appliances | Home tech: TVs, computers, smart home devices, wearables and more |
| Service fee / deductible model | Chosen service fee per visit; higher fee lowers plan price | Monthly plan; claim terms vary by item |
| Accidental damage cover | No | Not published |
| Claim channels | App, website, phone | Online, phone, app |
| Regions | US | US |
| Monthly billing option | Yes | Yes |
| One plan covers multiple items | Yes | Yes |
Verdict
Which should you pick?
Choose American Home Shield if…
You want something best for US homeowners wanting systems and appliance cover.
- + Covers systems and appliances in one plan
- + Choice of service fee
- + Monthly billing
Choose Asurion Home+ if…
You want something best for US households with many gadgets.
- + One plan for many devices
- + Includes tech support
- + Monthly billing
Checked 1 Nov 2026.
Questions
American Home Shield vs Asurion Home+: quick answers
Is American Home Shield better than Asurion Home+?
American Home Shield leads Asurion Home+ by 0.4 points overall (7.1 vs 6.7). American Home Shield scores higher on coverage breadth, fee structure clarity, regional availability. Asurion Home+ scores higher on repair network & parts.
Who should choose Asurion Home+ over American Home Shield?
Asurion Home+ is best for US households with many gadgets. American Home Shield is best for US homeowners wanting systems and appliance cover.
How were American Home Shield and Asurion Home+ scored?
Both were scored on the same 5 weighted criteria for home warranty & device protection plans, using public information such as published plans and terms. We do not lab-test products.